Skip to main content

Nigeria becomes Africa's biggest economy...again. Should we be impressed?

The news about Nigeria overtaking South Africa to become Africa's biggest economy, as the latter slipped into its second recession in as many years, was celebrated like a major achievement by a lot of people.

This would not be the first time that the West African Nation would lay claim to the title of being Africa's biggest economy. In 2014, Nigeria rebased its Gross Domestic Product (GDP) calculation to become Africa's biggest economy, but this claim has been subject to a lot of debate in recent times because it was largely dependent on which exchange rate was used in the calculation - the official rate of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), or the "market" rate.

This time, however, the Nigerian economy's claim is true regardless of the exchange rate that is used. The CBN rate (N306/$) and the market rate (N360/$) both put Nigeria's GDP ahead of South Africa at $476 billion and $402 billion respectively.

Being Nigerian, I would always cheer to see the Nation win even seemingly little battles such as "who has the best jollof rice - Nigeria or Ghana?", "which country is less corrupt :) - Nigeria or Zimbabwe?", "which country has the biggest economy in Africa?".

I did not feel great about this win this time, especially after I learned that the South African economy was in a recession and that Nigeria's GDP only grew by 2.3%.

An emerging market economy with a GDP growth of 2.3% is really not an achievement to be proud of, especially when you consider that it’s population is growing faster - at almost 3%. The already-poor country, Nigeria, isn’t growing fast enough to cater for its newborns.

In December 2019, I wrote about how Nigeria‘s GDP per capita (a measure of a country’s economic output that accounts for the number of people in that country) had been on a consistent decline for more than half of the decade. See tweet here.

According to the data, the average Nigerian was poorer by the end of the decade, than they were at the beginning. With 2019 results now in, this downward spiral did not improve. The trend did not just continue because the population is growing faster than the economy, but also because a 2.3% GDP growth rate is not sufficient for any emerging market economy that is serious about development and empowering its people.

Nigeria‘s case is unique. In 2018, the average GDP growth rate for all of West Africa was around 6%, however, Nigeria grew by 2%. In the first five years of the last decade (2010 to 2014), Nigeria's GDP grew at an average rate of 5.7%.

Emerging economies should, under normal circumstances, grow at much higher rates because, as  developing nations, they tend to have low hanging fruits that could be harvested with relative ease, provided that the right investments are made (in infrastructure, technology, education, welfare & security).

Education here does not necessarily mean formal / university education. I mean technical competence and skills - the type of technical education that propelled the Chinese economy into the powerhouse that it is today- We will get to this and other types of investments needed to drive growth in an emerging economy on another day / another blog post. Right now, Nigeria appears to be leaving its low hanging fruits to rot.

Outlook for 2020 - do I think 2020 will be better? Probably not, and I will explain why:

The Nigerian government (not the entire Nigerian economy, even though government spending is important in every economy) is heavily dependent on revenues from crude oil. With the #COVID19 putting extreme pressure on supply chains across the globe, the following is happening:

  • fewer factories are open in China - disrupting production activities in China also disrupts production across Europe, America and the rest of the world (this is both a risk and an opportunity for CEOs and leaders in other emerging market economies, respectively, as explained in this tweet;
  • fewer people are traveling for business or for vacation - as seen during the Chinese New Year celebration which is arguably the largest migration event on earth, people are just not traveling;
  • fewer people are driving to work / more are working from home;

What do these activities have in common? You guessed right: they all rely heavily on energy, a lot of which is derived from crude oil - the darling of the Nigerian government.

Unless the COVID-19 outbreak is contained soon, which is unlikely, and the global economy goes back to normal, government revenues and spending capacity are about to take a major hit.

Perhaps this is one of the reasons the government is looking to borrow $23 billion to fund investments. The investments (here) seem reasonable, perhaps, with the exception of the $500m planned for the digitization of the Nigerian Television Authority (NTA). This is clearly a misplaced priority.

These investments, if implemented properly, should hopefully help set the economy up for improved outcomes. However, as we all know, implementation has always been a stone-cold killer when it comes to African investments and the actualization of the "Africa Rising" narrative.

Should the government's plan for the loan fail during implementation, it would ironically mean that the government of the day is borrowing and spending money today which will need to be repaid by the same newborns which the government is already unable to cater for as mentioned above. 

Another concern is that any serious borrower would require a high return on capital because, as demonstrated earlier:

  • the Nigerian government struggles with implementation;
  • the government‘s chief source of revenue (crude oil) is being seriously threatened by the COVID-19 outbreak and is expected to be made worse as Russia breaks the OPEC alliance, which may result in oil producers flooding the market with "cheap" oil. If the market is flooded with oil as nations battle for market share, the price of crude oil will go down (remember 2014/15 & the recession that followed?);
  • Nigeria already has a currency that is considered overvalued and unreliable, regardless of which exchange rate you use; 

Surely, it cannot all be doom for the country. The Government is making a number of moves to help boost consumer spending, such as increasing the minimum wage by 67% and, through the CBN, forcing banks to make loans available to businesses by increasing the loan to deposit ratio for Nigerian banks. At this point, all we can do is hope for the best and for the odds to be in our favor. Nigeria is in dire need of "Goodluck".

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Declining Crude Oil Prices and the Nigerian Naira

With entire industries across the country currently shut down due to the Coronavirus, one source which had continued to generate the much-needed cash and foreign exchange for the Nigerian government was the sale of crude oil, albeit at lower prices . This week, prices declined even further, causing Nigeria’s Bonny Light crude oil blend to sell for around $12 and $13 per barrel. Despite the low price of crude oil, Nigeria currently has about 10 million barrels of unsold crude oil, and traders expect this number to increase in the following weeks and in the month of May. These low prices (compared with prices from 12 weeks before) and the inability to find buyers for the 10 million barrels at such low prices can be traced to the Coronavirus pandemic which is still spreading across the globe. With factories shut down, and transportation and other economic activities put on hold across Europe and Asia (some of Nigeria’s major buyers), there simply is not enough demand to match oil ...

Withdrawing your pension before retirement... today

“Without prejudice to subsection (1) of this section, any employee who disengages or is disengaged from employment before the age of 50 years and is unable to secure another employment within four months of such disengagement may make withdrawal from his retirement savings account in accordance with the provisions of section 7(2) and (3) of this Act” – Pension Reform Act, 2014. I have not had to quote the provisions of any Acts or Laws since I made the switch from being an International Tax consultant to being a Strategy and Transactions (M&A / Corporate Finance) advisor in 2016. It feels like a lifetime ago, and it was only about 13 months after the switch that I left Lagos for Stuttgart. Amidst the thoughts of uncertainty that plagued me as I prepared to leave home in August 2017, for a country where I did not know anyone or speak the language, I also wondered “what would happen to my pension when I leave?”. I managed to convince myself to deal with the present and onl...

Preserving vitality and sanity amidst all of the COVID-19 negativity

"Where there's life, there's hope". These words, famously echoed by Stephen Hawking, have never been more apt than in the situation we currently find ourselves in. The world is going through one of the worst crisis in modern history - healthcare, economic, political, etc., all happening at the same time, and it is difficult to predict when things will get back to normal, if things will ever get back to normal or what the new normal would be. There is an overwhelming amount of information that is being circulated across various media platforms. The substance of the information overload ranges from the educative, to the humorous. However, a significant amount of the information that comes to the mainstream are about negative occurrences around the world. A lot of negativity is being passed around in the form of news and statistics. While it is important to stay informed about what is going on around the world, it is also important to recognise the impact that all ...